The nonstick pan is the one piece of cookware most kitchens replace every few years. It starts out effortless, then the coating dulls, food starts grabbing, and eventually it goes in the bin, often while the pan underneath is still perfectly good.
The problem isn't just that nonstick wears out. PTFE coatings (the family that includes Teflon) start to break down at around 260°C / 500°F and release fumes, and a damaged coating can shed particles into food. A 2022 study in Science of the Total Environment (opens in a new tab) found that a single surface crack in a Teflon coating could release about 9,100 plastic particles, and a broken coating about 2.3 million. The coating is also the reason the pan has a short life: once it fails, the pan is done.
There's a wider reason, too. PTFE belongs to the PFAS family, the "forever chemicals" that don't break down in the environment; pans sold as "PFOA-free" still have a PTFE coating, and PTFE is itself classed as a PFAS under the OECD definition. These chemicals are now everywhere: a 2022 review in Environmental Science & Technology (opens in a new tab) found PFOA in rainwater above the US EPA's 2022 health advisory in every region with data, even the Tibetan Plateau. Swapping a pan won't change the rain, but it's one PFAS product you can take out of your own kitchen.
Cast iron and stainless steel have no coating to fail. What they have instead is technique: two skills that take about a week to learn and then last a lifetime. This post covers both: how to season cast iron, and how to use temperature to make stainless steel behave like nonstick.
The mindset shift
Nonstick is a product. Iron and steel are skills.
With nonstick, you buy the performance. With cast iron, you build it: a layer of polymerized oil called seasoning, baked onto the iron, that gets better the more you cook with it. With stainless steel, you earn it: the right preheat turns a sticky surface into one that releases food cleanly. Neither pan ever needs replacing because neither has anything to wear out.
Cast iron: how to season it
Seasoning is oil heated past its smoke point until it bonds to the iron as a hard, dry layer. It isn't one thick coat. It's several microscopically thin ones. The most common beginner mistake is using too much oil, which leaves a sticky, gummy finish instead of a hard one.
Starting from bare iron (a new unseasoned pan, or a pan you've stripped):
- Clean it. Scrub with hot water and a stiff brush. If the pan is new and waxy, wash it once with hot soapy water to remove the factory coating. Dry it completely: set it on a burner over low heat for a few minutes until every trace of water is gone.
- Oil it, barely. Rub a very thin coat of a high-smoke-point oil or fat over the whole pan, inside and out. Good choices: refined avocado oil, grapeseed oil, vegetable shortening, or plain vegetable oil. Then take a clean cloth and wipe it all off. If the pan looks like it has oil on it, there's too much. It should look almost dry.
- Bake it upside down. Place the pan upside down in an oven at 230–260°C / 450–500°F (above the oil's smoke point) for one hour. Upside down matters: any excess oil drips off instead of pooling and going sticky.
- Cool it in the oven. Let the pan cool in the oven before handling it.
- Repeat 2–3 times. Two or three thin layers give a solid base. After that, regular cooking does the rest.
If your pan came pre-seasoned (most new cast iron does), skip all of the above. Just cook with it. The factory seasoning is a starting layer, and your cooking builds on it.
A 25–30 cm / 10–12 inch skillet covers most cooking. Two that passed our check, with no coating and nothing but iron: Buy on Amazon → (opens in a new tab) and Buy on Amazon → (opens in a new tab), which is preseasoned with flaxseed oil.
Maintenance is simple:
- Clean with hot water and a stiff brush or a Buy on Amazon → (opens in a new tab). Mild dish soap is fine on a well-seasoned pan; modern dish soaps aren't the lye-based formulas that stripped seasoning in the past.
- Dry it on the burner over low heat, then rub in a few drops of oil while it's still warm.
- Don't soak it for hours, don't put it in the dishwasher, and don't clean it with oven cleaner. All three strip seasoning.
- Cook fatty foods early on: bacon, fried chicken, cornbread, vegetables roasted in oil. Every cook adds to the seasoning.
What cast iron isn't great at: long simmers of acidic food (tomato sauce, wine braises, citrus), which can dull fresh seasoning. That's what the stainless pan is for.
Stainless steel: how to make it nonstick with temperature
Food sticks to stainless steel for a simple reason: proteins bond to bare metal when the pan or the oil is too cold. The fix is the preheat. Get the pan hot before the oil and food go in.
The water test (the Leidenfrost test):
- Preheat the dry pan over medium heat for 2–3 minutes. No oil yet.
- Flick in a few drops of water. If they sizzle and evaporate, the pan is too cold, so wait longer. If the droplets bead up into little balls and glide across the surface, the pan is ready. That dancing stage is the Leidenfrost effect, and on most pans it starts somewhere around 190–215°C / 375–420°F.
- Add oil. It should shimmer immediately and flow freely. If it smokes heavily, the pan is too hot: pull it off the heat for a few seconds.
- Add food, patted dry. Wet food steams instead of searing, and steaming is what sticks. Pat meat, fish and vegetables dry with a towel first.
- Don't touch it. This is the hard part. Let the food form a crust, 30 to 90 seconds depending on what it is. When the crust forms, the food releases on its own. If it resists when you try to move it, it's not ready yet. Wait.
For eggs, the same method works with two adjustments: after the water test, turn the heat down slightly, and use a little more fat (butter or oil) than you think you need. Eggs are the least forgiving food on steel, so they're a good benchmark. Once you can do eggs, everything else is easy.
Cleaning: deglaze while the pan is still hot. Pour in a splash of water and the stuck bits lift right off (that's also the base of a pan sauce). For discolouration or rainbow heat stains, a paste of Bar Keepers Friend or baking soda and water takes it off without scratching.
A heavy, fully clad pan heats evenly and holds temperature, which makes the water test easier. Buy on Amazon → (opens in a new tab) has an 18/10 stainless cooking surface over an aluminum core, with a stainless handle and rivets.
Which one should you buy first?
- If you sear, fry, roast or bake cornbread: cast iron first. A 25–30 cm / 10–12 inch skillet covers most cooking.
- If you make sauces, deglaze, or cook acidic food often: stainless first. A 28 cm / 11 inch skillet with a heavy base is the workhorse.
Honest transition advice: you don't have to throw out your old nonstick today. Keep it for eggs while you learn the steel technique, and replace it once the new method clicks. No guilt. The goal is fewer throwaway pans, not a perfect kitchen overnight.
The middle ground: carbon steel seasons like cast iron but is lighter and heats faster. It's what most restaurant kitchens use. If you want one pan that does a bit of both, it's worth a look: Buy on Amazon → (opens in a new tab) is uncoated carbon steel with a welded steel handle, so there are no rivets either.
The long game
A decent cast iron skillet runs roughly $30–60, and a good stainless skillet $50–80. Either one can outlast a lifetime of nonstick replacements: pans you'd rebuy every 3–5 years, at $30–60 a time, while sending the old ones to landfill. The iron and steel pans your grandparents cooked with are still in kitchens today for a reason. There's nothing in them to wear out.
Learn the seasoning. Learn the water test. Your last nonstick pan can be your last one.
For more coating-free cookware, utensils and boards, browse the kitchen: cooking & prep section of our directory.
Frequently asked questions
Is it safe to cook with a scratched nonstick pan? A damaged PTFE coating can shed plastic particles into food, and PTFE releases fumes when overheated, starting at around 260°C / 500°F. If the coating is scratched or flaking, it's a good time to replace the pan with one that has no coating at all.
Can I use soap on cast iron? Yes. Mild modern dish soap won't strip a well-built seasoning. What does strip it: soaking for hours, the dishwasher, and oven cleaner.
Why does food stick to my stainless steel pan? Usually the pan wasn't hot enough when the food went in, or the food was wet. Preheat until water droplets bead up and glide, add oil, pat the food dry, and don't move it until a crust forms.
Is carbon steel better than cast iron? It's lighter and heats faster, and it seasons the same way. Cast iron holds heat longer, which is better for searing and baking. Both have no coating to wear out.
Sources checked October 2026.